Published February 6, 2021 | Version v1
Publication Open

Illocution and attitude

  • 1. Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais
  • 2. Universidade Federal do Pará

Description

This paper aims at investigating the prosodic relations between the category of illocution and that of attitude, the latter defined as the way the illocution (verbal action) is performed (Modis on Actum). We set three experiments and relative perception tests seeking to understand: (i) how different attitudes of the same illocution (Order) are perceived in different contexts; (ii) whether the illocutions of Order and Instruction are conveyed by the same prosodic form; (iii) how pragmatic/cognitive parameters work to accommodate a different prosodic form, using the illocutions of Offer and Question of Confirmation. We conclude that the methodology for the study of the illocutionary prosodic forms must pay close attention to the prosodic aspects of attitude, since they are always present when an illocution is performed, superposing their features over those of the illocution. We also claim that the identification of a specific illocution must consider some pragmatic and cognitive parameters, and not only prosody, since different illocutions can be prosodically performed with the same form. This becomes clear if we look for data in spontaneous speech corpora, where the pragmatic conditions can be at least partially reconstructed.

⚠️ This is an automatic machine translation with an accuracy of 90-95%

Translated Description (Arabic)

تهدف هذه الورقة إلى التحقيق في العلاقات العرضية بين فئة الإهانة والموقف، والتي تُعرَّف بأنها طريقة أداء الإهانة (الفعل اللفظي) (Modis on Actum). وضعنا ثلاث تجارب واختبارات إدراك نسبية تسعى إلى فهم: (1) كيف يتم النظر إلى المواقف المختلفة من نفس الطرح (الترتيب) في سياقات مختلفة ؛ (2) ما إذا كانت طقوس النظام والتعليم يتم نقلها بنفس الشكل العرضي ؛ (3) كيف تعمل المعلمات البراغماتية/المعرفية لاستيعاب شكل عرضي مختلف، باستخدام طقوس العرض ومسألة التأكيد. نستنتج أن منهجية دراسة الأشكال العرضية اللطيفة يجب أن تولي اهتمامًا وثيقًا للجوانب اللطيفة للموقف، لأنها موجودة دائمًا عند تنفيذ اللطافة، وتراكب ملامحها على ملامح اللطافة. ندعي أيضًا أن تحديد لغز معين يجب أن يأخذ في الاعتبار بعض المعلمات البراغماتية والمعرفية، وليس فقط العروض، لأن الطقوس المختلفة يمكن تنفيذها بشكل عفوي بنفس الشكل. يصبح هذا واضحًا إذا بحثنا عن بيانات في مجموعات الكلام العفوية، حيث يمكن إعادة بناء الشروط العملية جزئيًا على الأقل.

Translated Description (English)

This paper aims at investigating the prosodic relations between the category of illocution and that of attitude, the latter defined as the way the illocution (verbal action) is performed (Modis on Actum). We set three experiments and relative perception tests seeking to understand: (i) how different attitudes of the same illocution (Order) are perceived in different contexts; (ii) whether the illocutions of Order and Instruction are conveyed by the same prosodic form; (iii) how pragmatic/cognitive parameters work to accommodate a different prosodic form, using the illocutions of Offer and Question of Confirmation. We conclude that the methodology for the study of the illocutionary prosodic forms must pay close attention to the prosodic aspects of attitude, since they are always present when an illocution is performed, superposing their features over those of the illocution. We also claim that the identification of a specific illocution must consider some pragmatic and cognitive parameters, and not only prosody, since different illocutions can be prosodically performed with the same form. This becomes clear if we look for data in spontaneous speech corpora, where the pragmatic conditions can be at least partially reconstructed.

Translated Description (French)

This paper aims at investiggating the prosodic relations between the category of illocution and that of attitude, the latter defined as the way the illocution (verbal action) is performed (Modis on Actum). We set three experiments and relative perception tests seeking to understand : (i) how different attitudes of the same illocution (Order) are perceived in different contexts ; (ii) whether the illocutions of Order and Instruction are conveyed by the same prosodic form ; (iii) how pragmatic/cognitive parameters work to accommodate a different prosodic form, using the illocutions of Offer and Question of Confirmation. We conclu that the methodology for the study of the illocutionary prosodic forms must pay close attention to the prosodic aspects of attitude, since they are always present when an illocution is performed, superposing their features over those of the illocution. We also claim that the identification of a specific illocution must consider some pragmatic and cognitive parameters, and not only prosody, since different illocutions can be prosodically performed with the same form. This becomes clear if we look for data in spontaneous speech corporate, where the pragmatic conditions can be at least partially reconstructed.

Translated Description (Spanish)

This paper aims at investigating the prosodic relations between the category of illocution and that of attitude, the latter definid as the way the illocution (verbal action) is performed (Modis on Actum). We set three experiments and relative perception tests seeking to understand: (i) how different attitudes of the same illocution (Order) are percepived in different contexts; (ii) whether the illocutions of Order and Instruction are conveyed by the same prosodic form; (iii) how pragmatic/cognitive parameters work to accommodate a different prosodic form, using the illocutions of Offer and Question of Confirmation. We concluye that the methodology for the study of the illocutionary prosodic forms must pay close attention to the prosodic aspects of attitude, since they are always present when an illocution is performed, superposing their features over those of the illocution. We also claim that the identification of a specific illocution must consider some pragmatic and cognitive parameters, and not only prosody, since different illocutions can be prosodically performed with the same form. This becomes clear if we look for data in spontaneous speech corpora, where the pragmatic conditions can be at least partially reconstructed.

Files

10112.pdf

Files (641.7 kB)

⚠️ Please wait a few minutes before your translated files are ready ⚠️ Note: Some files might be protected thus translations might not work.
Name Size Download all
md5:ada13eaeb7ea2e5b7165def835d6d8cc
641.7 kB
Preview Download

Additional details

Additional titles

Translated title (Arabic)
الإيضاح والموقف
Translated title (English)
Illocution and attitude
Translated title (French)
Illocution et attitude
Translated title (Spanish)
Illocution and attitude

Identifiers

Other
https://openalex.org/W2941030511
DOI
10.20396/joss.v5i2.15062

GreSIS Basics Section

Is Global South Knowledge
Yes
Country
Brazil